Can a Dovish Fed Keep the Stock Market Rally Afloat?

The Dow Jones Industrial Average could be facing its third straight loss on Wednesday after losing over 270 points the last two sessions as investors digest the reality of slowing global growth. While the majority of markets are hoping for a U.S.-China trade deal, the other saving grace for the markets to keep the 2019 rally afloat is a dovish Federal Reserve.

Following the central bank’s decision to keep interest rates unchanged last month, there’s been a recurring theme of “patience” in Fedspeak as of late. Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell reiterated patience during last month’s press conference following the rate announcement and also mentioned that the U.S. economy is in a “good place.”

In move that was widely anticipated by most market experts, the Federal Reserve last month elected to keep rates unchanged, holding its policy rate in a range between 2.25 percent and 2.5 percent. In addition, the central bank alluded to no more rate hikes for the rest of 2019 after initially forecasting two.

However, with volatility returning to U.S. equities ahead of first-quarter earnings reports, how patient can investors get? Through Tuesday’s close, the markets are still roaring–the Dow is up 12 percent, the S&P 500 up 14.81 percent and the Nasdaq up 19.20 percent–but will that turn into a purr as 2019 wears on?

“March month-end marked the end of a substantial first-quarter rally in both stocks and bonds. Investors are wrestling with the question of whether dovish central banks will be sufficient to sustain the equity rally, even as economic growth may be slowing,” wrote ProShares global investment strategist Simeon Hyman in the new summary, First-Quarter Rally: But Will It Be Sustainable?.

Digesting a Global Slowdown

The reality of a slowing growth was made even more apparent as the International Monetary Fund cut its global growth forecast to the lowest level since the financial crisis, citing the impact of tariffs and a weak outlook for most developed markets. According to the IMF, the world economy will grow at a 3.3 percent pace, which is 0.2 percent lower versus the initial forecast in January.

This falls in line with other weak forecasts for growth.

“The Federal Reserve downgraded its estimate of 2019 growth from 2.3% to 2.1%,” Hyman noted. “This followed a similar downgrade from the European Central Bank, which downgraded its estimate for European 2019 growth from 1.6% to 1.2%.”

Profit Margins Peaking

Furthermore, Hyman pointed out that profit margins may have reached a ceiling, which could be evident when big banks start reporting their earnings this Friday. The following chart shows that trailing profit margins may have finally run out of steam after a decade-long climb.

Can a Dovish Fed Keep the Stock Market Rally Afloat 1

Wall Street analysts are already expecting a less-than-stellar earnings season for the first quarter.  Investors are looking at a 4.3 percent year-over-year reduction in earnings growth, according to FactSet estimates.

Should those estimates hold up, it would represent the first profit reduction for the S&P 500 since the second quarter of 2016. With analysts expecting a decline in earnings, the focus falls on corporate guidance for the rest of the year, which could help temper any investor fears.

“As noted in our chart of the month, S&P 500 margins are now higher than their pre-crisis peak,” Hyman wrote. “Among the items that could put pressure on margins is the erosion of pre-tax margins driven by the corporate tax cut.”

In addition, the rally in equities was also boosted by a fair share of share buybacks. Like nitrous oxide to a gasoline engine, this gave companies the ability to increase their share prices–a practice that has been called to question.

“Companies buying back shares may deserve a bit of extra scrutiny in 2019,” Hyman wrote. “Companies should return cash to shareholders if they have more cash than they need for worthwhile investment opportunities. But companies that buy back shares are specifically signaling that they only have temporary excess cash.”

Fed Watch in Effect

In terms of quantitative tightening, the Fed has been alluding to more flexibility with its holdings of Treasuries and mortgage-backed securities. The central bank has been on a path towards a reduction in assets, which would come prior to the end of 2019.

However, will this be enough to keep the rally going?

“The growth of the Fed’s balance sheet through quantitative easing was indeed a key force suppressing the level of longer-term interest rates,” Hyman noted. “There are, however, indications that as large as $3.5 trillion seems, it may actually be a neutral level.”

The notion floating around the capital markets is that the Fed will more than likely keep rates unchanged for most of 2019, but a rate cut also remains in the realm of possibilities. According to the CME Group’s FedWatch Tool, rates are forecasted to stay steady through the summer, but the possibility of a rate cut gets higher as the we head towards the fourth quarter.

Click here to read the full report by Hyman.

For more market trends, visit ETF Trends.