Don’t Lose Sight Of Sector Exposures Within Factor Indices

Broadly speaking, stocks within the same sector are often exposed to similar risk factors.  Investors with large energy sector exposures have certainly been reminded of this over the last six months.  This is precisely why segregating the U.S. equity universe by sector has been so appealing to investors over the years.  Over the last 16 years, the average annual return differential between the best and worst performing sector has been nearly 40%.

At their core, factor-based equity portfolios are nothing more than groups of securities that share common characteristic(s).  For example, the S&P 500 Pure Value Index includes members of the S&P 500 with the most attractive valuations as measured by earnings per share, book value to price value ratio and sales to price ratio.

Putting these two observations together – stocks within a factor portfolio and stocks within a sector sharing risk factors – it should be no surprise that pure factor portfolios can have sector concentrations that differ substantially from market-cap weighted benchmarks.

Within our U.S. Factor Defensive Equity strategy, we consider five factors: momentum, value, dividend growth, low volatility and small-cap.  The table below presents the current sector weights for five S&P indices that represent these factors.  Along with the sector exposures, we calculate a “Sector Diversification Score” for each of the factors as well as the overall S&P 500.  A Sector Diversification Score of 0 would indicate 100% exposure to a single sector while a Sector Diversification Score of 100 would indicate equal exposure to each of the nine sectors.

Four of the five factor indices tilt significantly – greater than 10 percentage points – away from the individual sector weights of the S&P 500.  This should not be worrying in the least bit.  If a portfolio looks exactly like a market-cap benchmark, then we surely can’t expect it to do any better than a market-cap weighted benchmark in helping an investor achieve investment goals.