Thematic ETFs and Nursery Rhymes: Good for the Goose, Good for the Gander | ETF Trends

By Toroso Asset Management

Last week, the client alignment growth factor of low fees culminated in further reductions from Vanguard and a filing from our partners at Tidal ETF Services and SoFi.

Thank you to Nate Geraci and Todd Rosenbluth for being on top of the news flow.

Themes, Themes, Good for Your Heart. The More You Eat…

In this week’s TETFindex update, we decided to focus on an innovation growth factors since client alignment was covered so much last week.

Client Alignment Growth Factors

Innovative Growth Factors

This week, we revisit Thematic ETF investing and explore how to use them in portfolio allocations.  When we first focused on thematic ETFs, we explored definitions and use cases. We will also explore how the tools in the can help investors evaluate the active share and smart cost.

ETF Industry Think Tank

Is 60/40 Humpty Dumpty?

The future of the traditional balanced portfolio, symbolized as 60% Global Equity (ACWI) and 40% Fixed Income (AGG) is quite limited according to many financial professionals:

60 40 Portfolio Broken

Within the ETF Thinktank, we have proposed to many members that incorporating high active share thematic ETFs may be an effective way of producing excess returns relative to the muted returns anticipated by the 60/40 balanced portfolio.

Fixed Income Global Equity Thematic

Old Mother Hubbard Visits A Cyber Security Expert

Theoretically this could work for future returns, but how would a buy and hold thematic allocation have enhanced a 60/40 model over the past 10, 5, or 3 years?  We built a number of models to compare, each with 10% of the equity allocation dedicated to a specific thematic ETF.  We compared each below to a traditional 60 ACWI/40 AGG model in Morningstar Direct.

Theme chart

Investors may be surprised to learn that, with the exception of Solar, all of these theme models generated excess returns in most or all longer buy and hold tests without a massive increase in volatility.

The Moral of the Rhyme

As ETF growth continues fueled by institutional adoption of lower and lower cost, the next wave will likely come from other innovations.  Thematic ETF investing is not new, but it has taken on its own identity separate from just subsectors.  At the, we are committed to fostering ETF growth through research that can help investors intelligently utilizes this new category.

This article was contributed by the team at Toroso Asset Management, a participant in the ETF Strategist Channel.

Click here to see disclosures.