In a previous blog post, we expressed the view that a tug-of-war was under way between the market and the Federal Reserve (Fed) surrounding the timing of the first rate hike. After a series of stops and starts, comments from a variety of Fed speakers and a slight pickup in some U.S. economic data, the Fed took the opportunity to deliver a dovish surprise at its March 18 policy meeting.1 In advance of Fed liftoff, we thought it would be interesting to examine how the market’s expectations have evolved over time. In our view, the current positioning in the Fed Funds futures market does not seem consistent with other market indicators about a potential shift in Fed policy. Additionally, current market positioning may be vulnerable to upward surprises in the economic outlook, similar to moves we saw last October.
Setting the Stage
Below, the graph to the left shows the evolution of Fed Funds futures prices on days of Federal Open Market Committee announcements that include updates to staff economic projections. Over these last three meetings, the market has gradually reduced the pace of interest rate hikes and delayed the date of the Fed’s first change in policy. At the most recent meeting, the staff projections showed meaningful downward revisions to the outlook. In the eyes of the market, the switch from time dependent to data dependent meant that rate hikes would likely occur later and at a slower pace.
However, the graph to the right shows a much different view of the market’s evolution. While it appears as though the Fed has gradually moved in the direction of the “lower for longer” camp, changes in market perceptions are much more volatile than the smooth downward adjustment that these three dates would suggest.
Evolution of Market Expectations
Implied Fed Funds Rate Using Fed Funds Futures
However, what is most interesting about the market’s recent reaction is that we have seen this exact market forecast before. On October 16, 2014, the shape of the Fed Funds futures curve was nearly identical to the market’s current outlook.2 In fact, as we show below, the results are within 2 basis points (bp) of one another all the way out through July 2016 (at which point the current market projections become even more bearish).
While it would be easy to write this off as coincidence, it’s remarkable that other assets, notably U.S. stocks and bonds, have shown a dramatic divergence from this view. With many markets taking cues from the Fed, market prices appear inconsistent with the market moves over the last couple of weeks. Since October 16, the S&P 500 Index is up nearly 14%. U.S. U.S. 2- Year Treasury note yields have risen from 34 bp to 61 bp, and 10-Year rates have fallen from 2.16% to 1.93%. Interestingly, the five-year breakeven inflation rate is virtually the same for both periods (1.48% versus 1.52%).1 While the dovish tilt in the market may ultimately prove correct, if we do regain economic momentum in key data releases in the coming weeks, the market is likely to react violently to such an upward change in expectations.