The 4% Rule for Retirement Returns in 2023 | ETF Trends

After a year of caution that first-year retirees should withdraw less than the standard 4% in 2022 to keep their retirement income plan on track, things may return closer to normal in 2023 according to the latest findings from Morningstar.

It was a challenging and painful year for retirement portfolios. Equities and bonds both sank, market volatility spiked for much of the year, and persistent, high inflation drove up the cost of living. The crunch on new retirees was especially strong as they were advised that retirement withdrawals should be limited to 3.3% for the first year. The authors of the report have since stated that they believe 3.3% might have been a high estimate for new retirees given the declines in bonds and stocks this year as well as high inflation.

The traditional 4% withdrawal rule has been long-established as a way to ensure that first-year retirees can maintain withdrawals from retirement portfolios at a steady pace over a 30-year time horizon while also rising over time to account for inflation. For 2023, Morningstar models calculated that a 3.8% withdrawal rate would be in line with maintaining the portfolio over the necessary time horizon.

“If you are thinking about retiring, you can use 3.8% as a test of the viability of the withdrawal you are considering,” Christine Benz, personal finance director at Morningstar and co-author of the research, told WSJ.

So, what changed? It turns out that when valuations are high, such as what has been the case leading up to this year, it’s one of the least ideal times to retire because of decreasing future investment returns. Now that those valuations have fallen, future returns are once again higher, allowing retirees to return to the more traditional withdrawal rate.

During periods of high inflation, withdrawals made according to the 4% rule jump because of adjustments to the high inflationary number. Coupled with the outsized effects that making withdrawals from a portfolio during a bear market can have by reducing holdings when a portfolio is already shrinking, it puts pressure on a portfolio to earn higher returns to compensate.

For first-time retirees or those early in retirement, it can be the set-up for significant challenges down the road and increases the risk of falling short of the retirement income time horizon.

For more news, information, and analysis, visit the Retirement Income Channel.

This article was prepared as part of Nationwide’s paid sponsorship of ETF Trends.

Call 1-800-617-0004 to request a summary prospectus and/or a prospectus, or download prospectuses at These prospectuses outline investment objectives, risks, fees, charges and expenses, and other information that you should read and consider carefully before investing.

The results shown represent past performance; past performance does not guarantee future results. Current performance may be lower or higher than the past performance shown, which does not guarantee future results. Share price, principal value and return will vary, and you may have a gain or a loss when you sell your shares. Returns for periods less than one year are not annualized. Short-term performance, in particular, is not a good indication of the fund’s future performance, and an investment should not be made based solely on returns. To obtain the most recent month-end performance, go to or call 1-877-893-1830.

KEY RISKS: The Nationwide Nasdaq-100® Risk-Managed Income ETF, Nationwide S&P 500® Risk-Managed Income ETF, Nationwide Dow Jones® Risk-Managed Income ETF, and Nationwide Russell 2000® Risk-Managed Income ETF (collectively, the “Risk-Managed Income ETFs”) are subject to the risks of investing in equity securities, including tracking stock (a class of common stock that “tracks” the performance of a unit or division within a larger company). A tracking stock’s value may decline even if the larger company’s stock increases in value. The Risk-Managed Income ETFs are subject to the risks of investing in foreign securities (currency fluctuations, political risks, differences in accounting and limited availability of information, all of which are magnified in emerging markets).

The Risk-Managed Income ETFs may invest in more-aggressive investments such as derivatives (which create investment leverage and illiquidity and are highly volatile). The Risk-Managed Income ETFs employ a collared options strategy (using call and put options is speculative and can lead to losses because of adverse movements in the price or value of the reference asset). The success of the Risk-Managed Income ETFs’ investment strategy may depend on the effectiveness of the subadviser’s quantitative tools for screening securities and on data provided by third parties. The Risk-Managed Income ETFs expect to invest a portion of their assets to replicate the holdings of an index. Correlation between Fund performance and index performance may be affected by Fund expenses and because the Fund may not be invested fully in the securities of the index or may hold securities not included in the index.

The Risk-Managed Income ETFs frequently may buy and sell portfolio securities and other assets to rebalance its exposure to various market sectors. Higher portfolio turnover may result in higher levels of transaction costs paid by the Risk-Managed Income ETFs and greater tax liabilities for shareholders. The Risk-Managed Income ETFs may concentrate on specific sectors or industries, subjecting them to greater volatility than that of other ETFs. The Risk-Managed Income ETFs may hold large positions in a small number of securities, and an increase or decrease in the value of such securities may have a disproportionate impact on the Funds’ value and total return. Although the Risk-Managed Income ETFs intend to invest in a variety of securities and instruments, the Risk-Managed Income ETFs will be considered non-diversified.

Additional risks include: Collared options strategy risk, correlation risk, derivatives risk, foreign investment risk, and industry concentration risk.

Nationwide Fund Advisors (NFA) is the registered investment advisor to Nationwide ETFs, which are distributed by Quasar Distributors LLC. NFA is not affiliated with any distributor, subadviser, or index provider contracted by NFA for the Nationwide ETFs.

Nationwide, the Nationwide N and Eagle and Nationwide is on your side are service marks of Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company. ©2022 Nationwide.

Information on this site should not be used or construed as an offer to sell, a solicitation of an offer to buy, or a recommendation for any product.

MFM-4979AO, Q-20221219-0555