Taking Stock of a big Consumer Discretionary ETF

“Firms in the sector have become leaner in the years since the financial crisis, although we question the big uptick in margins implied by consensus estimates for 2015-16, especially as savings at the gas pump aren’t being spent elsewhere, and estimates continue to drift lower. Valuation multiples have traded in a fairly narrow range over the past year — see the P/E ratio — but the sector remains richly valued versus the S&P500 in our opinion,” according to AltaVista.

Investors have added $261.3 million to XLY this year, but the fund still faces technical challenges.

“It is looking vulnerable at least near term. Last Friday, XLY found support at its 50-day moving average (76.18). Odds favor it loses that. There are some early signs of market participants preferring risk-off at the moment. Demand for VIX (Volatility Index) calls in June and July expirations – former in particular – has shot up; and of late in the futures market, June has seen a faster rise in price,” according to See It Market.

Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR