Why Active ETFs Are Outperforming Closest Passive Competitors

March 18, 2009 at 3:00 pm by Tom Lydon      Bookmark and Share

ETF active passiveActively managed exchange traded funds (ETFs) are ahead of their passive competitors, but so far PowerShares is still the only true provider for this relatively new niche investment tool.

Looking at the past three months and the last year, active stock ETFs by PowerShares are performing by as much as 5% better than their passive counterparts, writes Murray Coleman for IndexUniverse. PowerShares’ “active” ETFs provide a level of freedom to trade and don’t track a benchmark. It should be noted that these actively managed ETFs do have higher expense ratios compared to passive ETFs, but they’re still less expensive than mutual funds.

The four PowerShares active ETFs in the markets include:

  • PowerShares Active Mega Cap Fund (PMA), which is comprised of the best performing large-cap stocks last year, has outperformed its passive competitors, iShares S&P 100 Index (OEF) and the Vanguard Mega Cap 300 Index (MGC),  by 3.5-5% in the last three months. PMA includes around 30 mega-cap stocks, which tries to outperform the Russel Top 200 index, and so far fared better than the Russell by 5% for the year. Compared to MGC, PMA has more exposure to energy (21.7%), health care (25.2%), and technology (31.8%), but it has less exposure in consumer staples (6.6%), financials (6.8%), and industrials (1.8%).

  • PowerShares Active Alpha Multi-Cap Portfolio (PQZ) may take up a range of different stocks. It has done 3% better compared to the average multi-cap core mutual fund and the Lipper multi-cap index. Compared to its closest competitor, Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF (VTI), it has more sector allocations in technology (40%) and materials (15.7%), but it is lighter in consumer discretionary (1.9%), consumer staples (3.4%), health care (9.7%), industrials (3.8%) and no exposure to utilities.

  • PowerShares Active AlphaQ Fund (PQY) is made of 50 top-ranked names from the Nasdaq composite benchmark. Its passive rival, the PowerShares QQQ (QQQQ), seems to be doing a little bit better. PQY differs in the fact that it holds around 6.5% in financials. It now holds 49.8% in technology and lately it is has been holding more in software companies. Furthermore, PQY has no allocations in energy.

  • PowerShares Active Real Estate Fund (PSR) focuses on real estate investment trusts with most investments in REITs. It has beaten broad-based index tracking funds, like the Vanguard REIT Index ETF (VNQ). Managers of PSR may select stocks of non-REITs with large real estate holdings that don’t distribute earnings and they are given the option to temporarily invest in cash under market distress.

Max Chen contributed to this article.

Share this post:
  • email
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Tipd
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Facebook
  • Technorati
  • Google Bookmarks
  • TwitThis

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Subscribe to Our Daily E-mail Newsletter

Enter your e-mail address below to sign up for our daily e-mail newsletter, the Daily Market Update. We will never share your e-mail address with third parties.

Subscribe to Our RSS Feed

Click here to subscribe to our RSS feed

  • Sean Rowland
    Curious on any thoughts, opinions and concerns on the Powershares RMBS and Alt-A RMBS. I have read the SEC filing and press release - nothing else has realy been said or written as far as I know. Is there investor interest in this? Is the pricing and active mgt features feasable and practical?

    I think there may be a market for some mtg exposure and the "toxic asset bonds" in an ETF style distrubution. Retail could then get a piece of the PPIP/PPIF pie. Definately needs an active management feature to it though.

    Thanks
  • Tom Lydon
    Thanks for your comment, Sean.

    I trust that PowerShares has looked into this market and they know what they're doing. I would consider buying this immediately after it launches, but watch the funds: keep an eye on the news and watch trading to get an assessment of whether there's an active market for this area.

    Look for more from us as these funds launch. It may take some time for them to come to market, though.
blog comments powered by Disqus
Special Report

Recent TV Appearances

Now Available:

The ETF Trend
Following Playbook

ETF Trends' new book is now available. Click here for details. Or order online from one of these bookstores:
Amazon        Barnes and Noble


iMoney

ETF Trends' book iMoney is available. Click here for details. Or order online from one of these bookstores:
Amazon        Amazon