Lehman Failure Illustrates Risks of ETNs

September 16, 2008 at 1:00 pm by Tom Lydon      Bookmark and Share

One of the ways in which exchange traded notes (ETNs) differ from exchange traded funds (ETFs) is that they’re debt instruments. This means that you’re taking on the credit risk of the issuer, and if the issuer goes under, you lose your money.

The demise of Lehman Brothers (LEH) serves to illustrate some of the risks that investors need to be aware of. In February, Lehman had launched three ETNs tracking a private equity, agricultural commodities and a broad-based commodity index. What will happen to these funds isn’t clear yet, but the industry is watching closely. Whatever does happen could have implications for how investors approach ETNs going forward.

According to Ian Salisbury for Dow Jones Newswires, investors have put $7.2 billion into ETNs since their invention by Barclays in 2006.

While ETNs are debt securities that are usually issued by investment banks, their structure gives them greater flexibility. They’re easier to design around hard-to-reach assets such as commodities or countries that have limits on foreign investment, such as India.

But investors need to know that if the issuer goes under, there’s little recourse. Salisbury points out that the question might be an academic one: none of the ETNs issued by Lehman has more than $6 million in assets. Money in the funds probably represents capital kept there by specialist firms who are making sure they trade in an orderly fashion.

Firms with more popular ETNs, it should be noted, have significant assets and trading volumes. Both Barclays and Deutsche Bank appear to be financially sound, and their ETNs are issued by units with investment-grade credit ratings.

Trading in the funds was halted on Monday:

  • Opta Lehman Brothers Commodity Index Pure Beta Total Return (RAW)
  • Opta Lehman Brothers Commodity Index Pure Beta Agriculture Total Return (EOH)
  • Opta S&P Listed Private Equity Index Net Return (PPE)
Share this post:
  • email
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Tipd
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Facebook
  • Technorati
  • Google Bookmarks
  • TwitThis

Tags: , , , , ,

Subscribe to Our Daily E-mail Newsletter

Enter your e-mail address below to sign up for our daily e-mail newsletter, the Daily Market Update. We will never share your e-mail address with third parties.

Subscribe to Our RSS Feed

Click here to subscribe to our RSS feed

  • Anonymous
    Has anyone also noticed that etf securities (not all but many etfs) have been suspended from trading? they are partners with AIG. i think counter-party risk is truly taking on a new definition!!!
  • Tom Lydon
    Yes, we've been taking a look at that story. So far, we haven't noticed any issues, but we're digging into it!

    http://www.moneymarketing.co.uk/cgi-bin/item.cg...
  • David
    What if you short an ETN, and the investment bank that issued them goes under . . . Aren't you safe then? . . . In fact don't you make a windfall profit since the ETN basically goes to zero theoretically?
  • Tom Lydon
    Hi David,

    We're working on an answer for you. Thanks for your patience!
  • Tom Lydon
    Hi David,

    Shorting an ETN is not the best idea for a couple reasons:

    1) The indicative value doesn't reflect the credit of the issuer; it's more linked to the underlying assets in the ETN
    2) When you sell short, someone has to locate someone to borrow shares. If everyone's scrambling to get out, you might get bought in on your short.
blog comments powered by Disqus
Special Report

Recent TV Appearances

Now Available:

The ETF Trend
Following Playbook

ETF Trends' new book is now available. Click here for details. Or order online from one of these bookstores:
Amazon        Barnes and Noble


iMoney

ETF Trends' book iMoney is available. Click here for details. Or order online from one of these bookstores:
Amazon        Amazon