Actively Managed Mutual Funds Make ETFs Look Good By Underperforming

March 08, 2008 at 1:00 am by Tom Lydon

1950504803 Actively managed mutual fund enthusiasts say that a bear market is where active stock picking can beat index funds or exchange traded funds (ETFs).

Jonathan Chevreau for Financial Post takes a look at the Standard & Poor’s Indices Versus Active Funds (SPIVA) scorecard, which seems to indicate that it isn’t so. 

Only 24.3% of actively managed Canadian equity funds outperformed the S&P/Toronto Stock Exchange (TSX) composite index in 2007, while only 37% of beat the S&P/TSX Canadian Dividend Aristocrats Index. Out of five years, only 10% of actively managed Canadian equity funds beat the TSX, while over 3 years only 13.3% did so.

Canadian small-mid caps did capture some fame with actively managed stock picking coming out ahead. In 2007, 51.8% of Canadian small-mid-cap equity funds did manage to beat the S&P/TSX Completion Index.

In the United States, it isn’t much better: actively managed U.S. and international equity funds also performed poorly against the indexes. Over 5 years, only 13.1% of international equity funds beat the index, while 14.9% of U.S. equity mutual funds did so.

Ouch. If you can’t beat the market, why don’t you just buy the market?

Tags: , ,

Share: DiggDigg | Del.icio.usBookmark at Del.icio.us | Tip'd

Subscribe to our RSS Feed

Click here to subscribe to our RSS feed

Leave a Reply

Subscribe to E-mail Newsletter

Enter your e-mail address below to sign up for our free e-mail newsletter, the Daily Market Update. We will never share your e-mail address with third parties.

ETF Analyzer

iMoney

ETF Trends' new book iMoney is now available. Click here for details. Or order online from one of these bookstores:
Amazon        Amazon

    • Dave: Jim Cranmer is trying to eliminate these investment vehicles
    • Tom Lydon: Hi Steven, Among the many muni bond ETFs available are: * PowerShares Insured National Muni Bond (PZA) *...
    • Steven Ely: Could you please tell me where I can get a list of Muni Bonds that are on a watch list. I am a very small...
    • Tom Lydon: Santosh, Closed-end funds are launched through an initial public offering that raises a fixed amount of...
    • Michael Russnow: You ought to look at the following short video produced in Cologne, Germany by TV Star Andreas...

Recent Podcast

Tom Lydon on Gaining an Edge with ETFs

 
 Tom Lydon on Gaining and Edge with ETFs: Play Now | Play in Popup | Download